29 July 2024

Attendees

  • Andreas Reich, TrustNXT

  • Andy Rosen

  • Candice Ward

  • Christian Paquin, Microsoft

  • Cole Davis, Switchchord

  • David Bigsby, Government of British Columbia

  • Drummond Reed, Gen Digital

  • Eric Scouten, Adobe

  • Gavin Peacock, Adobe

  • Jesse Carter, CIRA

  • Karen Kilroy, FileBaby

  • Konrad Bleyer-Simon, Global Media Registry

  • Lindsay Walker, Starling Labs

  • Liviu Gheorghe, Adobe

  • Loren Hart, Noosphere Technologies

  • Michael Becker, Identity Praxis

  • Misha Deville, Vidos

  • Pamela Dingle, Microsoft

  • Peleus Uhley, Adobe

  • Pia Blumenthal, Adobe

  • Richard W. Kroon, EIDR

  • Scott Perry, Digital Governance Institute

  • Sébastien Testeau, Radio Canada

  • Slava Asipenko, Proof

  • Tim Cappalli, Okta

  • Will Kreth, HAND (Human & Digital) Identity

Notes

New members introduction

  • 🎥 1'05": Liviu Gheorghe, Adobe

  • 🎥 2'23": Slava Asipenko, Proof

  • 🎥 3'18": Tim Cappalli, Okta

Review PR #138: Section on credential revocation

🎥 4'17": Review PR #138: Write up section on credential revocation.

ACTION (✅): Eric to make minor wording changes as discussed in the meeting and merge.

Ratification vote on identity 1.0

🎥 30'26": Decided, in light of the lengthy discussion on revocation above, to wait one more week on ratification.

IMPORTANT: We will vote on ratification of the 1.0 version of the identity assertion in the 5 August 2024 meeting.

ACTION (✅): Eric to prepare PR that removes the example questions section from the “Name collisions” section.

Open issues for identity 1.x

🎥 33'38": Several PRs and issues were opened against the VC portion of the 1.x draft.

Clerical changes made last week: Adding section numbers and a few minor wording/proofreading changes.

PR #157: Unify namedActor, affiliations, and identities into a single verifiedIdentities property

🎥 33'38": Review PR #157: Unify namedActor, affiliations, and identities into a single verifiedIdentities property.

ACTION: Liviu to re-read PR and approve. Group otherwise approves merge.

PR #147: Remove requirement for id field

🎥 41'35": Review PR #147: Remove requirement for id field.

ACTION (✅): Eric to merge.

PR #146: Remove issuer section

🎥 42'56": Review PR #146: Remove issuer section.

ACTION (✅): Eric to modify the PR to retain a link to the VC data model section on issuer and merge.

Issue #151: Review description of boundTo property

🎥 45'21": Discuss issue #151: Review description of boundTo property.

ACTION (✅): Eric to create PR with the following changes:

  • Rename boundTo to c2paAsset.

  • Specify that no conversion between camelCase and snake_case should be performed.

  • Specify which Base-64 encoding must be used.

ACTION (any interested members): Review PR #159, which makes the above changes.

Issue #155: Write section on proof mechanisms

🎥 50'06": Discuss Issue #155: Write section on proof mechanisms.

ACTION (any interested members): Review comments added in above issue. Group is leaning toward requiring CBOR signatures for consistency with C2PA claim generator signature.

Issue #115: Provide meaningful differentiation between similarly-named actors

🎥 54'54": Discuss Issue #115: Provide meaningful differentiation between similarly-named actors.

ACTION (✅): Eric to close as not currently feasible.

Issue #64: Consider stronger timestamping mechanism than W3C VC requires

🎥 1h14'08": Discuss Issue #64: Consider stronger timestamping mechanism than W3C VC requires

Unresolved. Carry over to future meeting.