22 July 2024

Attendees

  • Andy Parsons, Adobe

  • Andy Rosen

  • Candice Ward

  • Carly Huitema, U of Guelph

  • Cole Davis, Switchchord

  • David Bigsby, Government of British Columbia

  • Drummond Reed, Gen Digital

  • Eric Scouten, Adobe

  • Gavin Peacock, Adobe

  • Jesse Carter, CIRA

  • Karen Kilroy, FileBaby

  • Konrad Bleyer-Simon, Global Media Registry

  • Leonard Rosenthol, Adobe

  • Lindsay Walker, Starling Labs

  • Loren Hart, Noosphere Technologies

  • Michael Becker, Identity Praxis

  • Nigel Earnshaw, BBC

  • Pamela Dingle, Microsoft

  • Patrick Boehler, independent consultant

  • Peleus Uhley, Adobe

  • Pia Blumenthal, Adobe

  • Scott Perry, Digital Governance Institute

  • Will Kreth, HAND (Human & Digital) Identity

Notes

Review PRs for identity 1.0

#141: Changed trust triangle to trust diamond

🎥 2'15": Review PR #141: Changed trust triangle to trust diamond in 9.1.

ACTION (✅): Eric to make minor wording changes as discussed in the meeting and merge.

#138: Credential revocation

🎥 9'02": Review PR #138: Write up section on credential revocation.

ACTION (✅): Eric to adjust wording:

  • Any evidence about revocation should be part of the identity assertion consumer’s report on the identity assertion.

  • Revocation at time of signing should be cause for choosing untrusted status.

ACTION (interested members): Please review proposed new wording based on today’s meeting.

#136: Formalize trusted, well-formed, and revoked status for identity assertion signatures

🎥 42'09": Review PR #136: Formalize trusted, well-formed, and revoked status for identity assertion signatures.

ACTION (✅): Eric to adjust wording to avoid implication that credential issuer must perform the revocation. Approved to merge after that change.

Updated draft available

An updated draft incorporating #141 and #136 is available here.

1.0 ratification vote next week

🎥 49'18": Discuss ratifaction vote. Agreed to proceed with ratification next week.

IMPORTANT: We will vote on ratification of the 1.0 version of the identity assertion in the 29 July 2024 meeting.

ACTION (all members): Very last call for review of the 1.0-draft spec. Please flag any items that feel like blockers to you.

Training and data mining assertion 1.1-draft

🎥 49'43": Eric proposed to open a working draft for a future (1.1) version of the training and data mining assertion specification.

The only changes so far since the approved 1.0 draft are:

  • New version "1.1-draft".

  • Revert language in "Contributing" section from approved to working draft.

  • Adding a note stating that an approved 1.1 version is expected late this year.

Additional changes are expected and the 1.1-draft text provides space for that work to proceed.

DECISION: Approved.

ACTION (✅): Eric to promote 1.1 from pre-draft to draft.

Review identity assertion 1.x

🎥 53'08": Review the 1.x-draft version of the identity assertion.

ACTION: Eric to convene subgroup meeting later in the week to revise 8.1.1 example to match likely usage pattern.

ACTION (✅): Eric to merge PR #126: Add VC schema description. Group agreed that having two separate drafts for the VC version of this specification was confusing.

ACTION: Eric to review TO DO items and add GitHub issues.

FYI there is active work underway at Adobe to validate this part of the spec in code. See GitHub: scouten-adobe/cawg-identity-core. Be aware this is very early code.